CredLedger

Best Pizza Shops in Gibsonia

Gibsonia, Pittsburgh, PA · 16 businesses ranked by CredScore.

Rankings can’t be bought. Updated

About this ranking

These are the most credible pizza shops serving Gibsonia in Pittsburgh, PA. Every business is scored on its public reputation — review quality, volume, and consistency — not on advertising spend. Right now, Off The Vine Pizza Pie leads with a CredScore of 93.3.

Ranked list

  1. 1

    Off The Vine Pizza Pie

    4.7 (105) 160 Brickyard Rd Ste 400, Mars, PA 16046, USA
  2. 2

    Siciliano's Pizzeria

    4.7 (88) 86 E Union Rd #1710, Cheswick, PA 15024, USA
  3. 3

    Stello's Pizzeria

    4.6 (289) 10 Creighton Russellton Rd, Russellton, PA 15076, USA
  4. 4

    Supremo's Pizzeria

    4.6 (238) 641 PA-228, Mars, PA 16046, USA
  5. 5

    Monte Cello's | Italian Restaurant

    4.5 (2,075) 2198 Babcock Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15209, USA
  6. 6

    Luciano's Italian Brick Oven

    4.5 (1,321) 161 Scharberry Ln, Mars, PA 16046, USA
  7. 7

    Lettopalena's Pizza and Italian Cuisine

    4.5 (220) 1155 Pittsburgh Rd, Valencia, PA 16059, USA
  8. 8

    Pizza Roma

    4.4 (313) 928 PA-910, Cheswick, PA 15024, USA
  9. 9

    Angelo's Pizzeria West Deer

    4.4 (51) 2033 Saxonburg Blvd, Tarentum, PA 15084, USA
  10. 10

    Mars Pizza

    4.3 (158) 129 Grand Ave, Mars, PA 16046, USA
  11. 11

    Carlucci's Pizza

    4.3 (273) 657 Castle Creek Dr, Seven Fields, PA 16046, USA
  12. 12

    Peppino's Pizza

    4.2 (70) 4081 Adair Ave, Valencia, PA 16059, USA
  13. 13

    Venice Pizzeria

    4.1 (245) 4144 Saw Mill Run Blvd, Brentwood, PA 15227, USA
  14. 14

    Cenci's Pizzeria & Bar

    4.1 (851) 3005 Fairport Ln, Cranberry Twp, PA 16066, USA
  15. 15

    AJ's Pizza

    4.0 (25) 3565 Harts Run Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15238, USA
  16. 16

    Fox's Pizza Den

    4.0 (104) 908 Little Deer Creek Valley Rd, Russellton, PA 15076, USA

How CredScore works

CredScore is a single 0–100 figure derived from each business’s public reputation signals. It is computed by an automated pipeline and refreshed on every site build. Placement on this page cannot be purchased, and paying to claim a profile does not change a business’s rank.